SubscribeGift a Sub
Enable cache 100

HI Spy: Does Your Horse See a Boogeyman on the Bridle Path?

Forget the lions, tigers and bears. Oh my! More often it’s the trash cans, motorcycles and street signs that make our otherwise brave trail horses shiver in their shoes.  Though there are a handful of truly bombproof horses out there—or so the legend goes—almost every horse will spook at something on the trail. Whether it’s the sneaky dog that lies in wait and then leaps at the fence like a rabid coyote, or the gardener wielding a weedwhacker, our horses have their phobias. Sometimes a horse is cruising down the bridle path only to be surprised by an artifact (empty pizza box, anyone?) that sends him whirling in the opposite direction. Other more contemplative horses become transfixed by mysterious objects.



“I consider my Thoroughbred gelding, Rusty, to be pretty brave,” says Schuyler Jones, who cruises the trails about once a week to give her jumper a break from arena work. “Traffic doesn’t bother him. Neither do other farm animals, even the sort of odd ones like llamas and potbellied pigs. But heaven forbid we ride past a house that’s been landscaped with decorative boulders. Rusty just comes to a complete standstill. He’s never actually bolted off or anything like that. But he just locks up, like he cannot figure out what those giant, misshapen objects are or why they’re sitting on someone’s lawn. After a couple of minutes, I can finally get him going again. But then he’s scoping out every front yard for a while, to see if there are any granite monsters lurking about.”



We’d like to know what hypnotizes your horse on the trails. Is it questionable choices in lawn ornamentation? Or does your horse snort and scoot when it comes to crossing water or a busy street? We want to know the one thing that always seems to send your horse into flight mode when you’re out on the trail. To contribute, just click on Submit a Comment below. Some of the best responses will be featured in an upcoming issue of Horse Illustrated.

See more HI Spy Questions >>

Cindy Hale

Cindy Hale’s life with horses has been filled with variety. As a child she rode western and learned to barrel race. Then she worked as a groom for a show barn, and was taught to harness and drive Welsh ponies. But once she’d taken her first lessons aboard American Saddlebreds she was hooked on English riding. Hunters and hunt seat equitation came next, and she spent decades competing in those divisions on the West Coast. Always seeking to improve her horsemanship, she rode in clinics conducted by world-class riders like George Morris, Kathy Kusner and Anne Kursinski. During that time, her family began raising Thoroughbred and warmblood sport horses, and Cindy experienced the thrills and challenges of training and showing the homebred greenies. Now retired from active competition, she’s a popular judge at local and county-rated open and hunter/jumper shows. She rides recreationally both English and western. Her Paint gelding, Wally, lives at home with her and her non-horsey husband, Ron.

View Comments

  • My horse is a huge scaredy-cat! Sometimes, it makes me laugh, especially when there is nothing there. I feel bad for him, though. If I ride him out on the trails more than once in a week, then he's fine. If I don't ride him that often, then he freaks out.

  • My horse is a bit of a scaredy cat at times. She doesn't like water and will do almost anything to avaoid getting her feet wet. She also hates plastic bags, and squirrels that she thinks are going to eat her!

  • Mine spooks at deer every time. The first time he discovered his phobia, he startled me so much I fell off. I expect it now so I don't fall off anymore but I'm trying to show him deer are NOT crazed beasts that are certain to chase him down.

  • My filly has spooked at a century 21 for sale sign flapping in the wind and creaking. She also dislikes small children running around but on the whole, enjoys a good hack. My appendix quarter horse gelding however, is convinced that the trails are full of monsters! One of his biggest problems is a row of small pine trees a house down the way has planted in their yard!

  • Yes, there are a handful of horses out there who are bombproof, but even bombproof horses have their scary objects. I've worked with the most bombproof horses I've ever met for years, and it was the most bombproof one that we had the worst incident with. This gelding, a big, muscular, problably around 16.1 Quarter Horse, was invincible. I've seen him standing out in the field, pinned between the fence and a horse that was clearly telling him to go away, pinning, then resorting to biting him repeatedly on the ear, and this horse just stood there throwing his head every time he was bitten. He was the horse we gave the least experienced riders. Even though he was only 6, he took the best care of his riders, doing exactly what they told him to do, going over bridges, through mud, walking through a creek... and he had had nervous riders on him before. However, we found out the hard way that he was most afraid of rider fear. A girl scout got on him to go on a trail ride, but she was really scared. Everyone knows that when the rider is nervous, the horse also gets nervous. He did, and if that wasn't enough, a pole got knocked down and touched him on the way down, and the girl who was handling him got startled and screamed. That was the last straw for this poor horse, who ripped out of the girl's hands and ran out of the arena with the screaming Girl Scout, abruptly stopping short of a fence, where the Girl Scout promptly fell off and hurt her wrist. She was crying, the horse was trembling, and it was overall a BAD situation. Well, we made sure to take a bunch of time out of our afternoon that day for desensitization, for him, as well as a couple other horses and ponies that we put kids on regularly.

  • My horse is also afraid of large rocks, white ones in particular. He likes to think there's something waiting to eat him around every corner but rocks are what really push him over the edge. He usually just whirls around to run as far away from it as possible but he hasn't actually taken off yet. After an encounter with a rock though it takes him a while to calm down again.

  • I was once riding a paint gelding named Chief and It was the first time riding him and we took him out on a trail and he was doing fine until I tried to guide him around a corner and he totally freaked out and started jumping all over and resufed to turn the corner. I COULD NOT get him to to. There was nothing around except trees. I felt him tense up so I grabed the saddle horn and dug my heels down becuase I thought he was going to bolt back to where we came from. after a minute one of my friends I was riding with had to lead there horse over to him and grad the bridle and lead him back. After that he was the best horse on the trail. I guess it was just one of those horsey moments on the trail :)

  • Of all the things that spook my horse on the trail, I think that the other horses are the biggest, I always ride on the same trails so theres not really anthing else to be scared of.

  • My horse Blaze never spooks at anything when we go out trail riding he loves to look at the birds and we ride with deer too. But heaven forbid if we go by the trash can at the end of our farms driveway. It is only that one trash can.

  • My instructors horse Angel is the spookiest horse around. Even when the wind blows, she hops & jumps around all scared. When you say her name she will jump as if your voice was a firecracker, even when you weren't yelling!

Recent Posts

An Overview of White Line Disease

It's often what you can’t see that leads to trouble, and that’s definitely the case with white line disease. Understanding…

4 days ago

ASPCA Right Horse Adoptable Horse of the Week: My Man Ira

Welcome to Horse Illustrated’s weekly installment of the Right Horse Adoptable Horse of the Week, offered in partnership with the…

5 days ago

Riding Lipizzaners in Hungary

Two hours’ drive from Budapest in the picturesque Bükk National Park lies Szilvásvárad, a beautiful little village that is home…

6 days ago

How Horses Helped Two Boys with ADHD

During the height of the pandemic and racial tension around the U.S., two boys struggling with ADHD found healing through…

7 days ago

Adopting a Companion Horse

When you think of the term “companion horse,” one that is versatile with the ability to fill a variety of…

1 week ago

Emergency and Natural Disaster Preparedness with Horses

Each year, hurricanes, wildfires, and severe storms force thousands across the country to evacuate their homes. When preparing for a…

2 weeks ago