A federal judge has dismissed Dekalb, Ill.-based Cavel International’s challenge to a new Illinois law that bans equine slaughter. Illinois Gov. Rod Blagojevich signed the law in May banning the import, export, possession and slaughter of horses intended for human consumption.
Cavel, which processes horses for human consumption overseas, was ordered to shut down last week while the judge considered the company’s challenge to the Illinois law. But on Thursday the judge threw out the case, saying that Cavel’s claims that the law is unconstitutional were without merit. Now Cavel will remain permanently closed unless it can win an appeal to this latest ruling.
Cavel attorney Phil Calabrese said an appeal was likely, but that he first had to talk with his client about the ruling. “We are disappointed in the ruling and respectfully disagree with it,” Calabrese said.
Cavel, which is located about 60 miles west of Chicago, primarily shipped its horsemeat overseas for human consumption. A portion of its meat also was sold to U.S. zoos.
Cavel operated for about 20 years and slaughtered about 1,000 horses a week, according to plant officials.
Two other U.S. plants, both in Texas, closed earlier this year. A federal appeals court upheld a Texas law banning horse slaughter for human consumption, and the U.S. Supreme Court refused to take up the case. The closures mark the end of a decades-long practice of slaughtering horses in the United States for human consumption overseas.
Missed the Story? Catch up with previous news coverage:
Illinois Bans Horse Slaughter for Meat
Last remaining slaughter plant remains open
Illinois Takes Steps to Ban Slaughter
The last U.S. slaughterhouse is ordered to close
Join the Discussion! Chat Now >>
Welcome to Barn Banter, the official podcast of Horse Illustrated. In Barn Banter episode 29, hosts Susan Friedland and Horse Illustrated…
The nurse mare industry has been a source of controversy over the years, but practices are changing—meaning a better outlook…
Horse ownership comes with incredible rewards: the thrill of a pleasure ride, the camaraderie of competition, and the deep bond…
By tapping the power of neuroscience and the miracle of brain plasticity, spending just a few minutes a day practicing…
The U.S. horse slaughter industry is as hot-button an issue as there is. Find out where current legislation stands with…
You may have wondered if you can take the edge off an anxious horse or add pep to a lazy…
View Comments
Hallelujah!!God is SO GOOD!!!!These Horses need another chance to live,and with this slaughterhouse(I hate that word)closed,they get a second chance.
Adopt from an Equine Rescue center.like http://www.habitatforhorses.org a lot of the horses there have been rescued from slaughter,abuse and neglect,and they deserved the second chance!!
Horse Lover
Umm... OK why don't you go adopt some horses then. Oh that's right you don't have any more room for another horse. What makes you think the rest of us do? Well,.. get ready folks for the onset of repercussions this is going to produce. More neglect, shelters and adoption agencies packed and unable to find homes for there horses, having to turn more away. Its happening already I know of several agencies begging for foster help. Plus there is a lot more free horses advertised than ever and horse values are set to start depreciating also. Slaughter isn't great but is that really what people had a problem with or was it just the way horses where slaughtered? And did they just out law slaughter for humane consumption or does it cover all horse slaughter? Why didn't we try and figure out a humane way of slaughtering them instead of shutting them down? Because it was easier to just shut them down. And now if the profits are great enough they'll just move to another state so problem avoided not fixed.