Don't forget the "Minnie Mouse" white hands at the end of those tanned arms. Definitely an odd look, too.
That's the same exact problem I have! My arms and face are dark brown, but my legs aren't white as snow, but they're white. This summer I'm going to put aside sometime to tan my white legs.
I wear jeans all summer too, even to play tennis. If people think I'm wierd, I really don't care. Some actually ask me why I'm wearing jeans at 120 degrees and I'm like, 'um...uh,' and then I laugh nervously. But maybe that's not exactly the response they're looking for...