SubscribeGift a Sub
Enable cache 100

Who Would Do this to Horses?

I’m glad July is over. A pair of sad stories regarding horses put a bit of gloom into what should have been a month filled with trail rides aboard Wally. I’ll share them with you not because I want to spread the sorrow around, but so we can all be aware of what some people are capable of doing to horses. Perhaps if we’re tuned in to how some minds work (or don’t work) we can be on the lookout for neglect and mistreatment.
Here is the first instance, from a brief report filed by the Associated Press on July 16:



Authorities say five horses found dead in a pasture near Tracy, California, appeared to have died of thirst. San Joaquin County deputies say the horses were left without water in 90-degree temperatures for at least three days before being found in the pasture in an unincorporated area near Tracy.



Sheriff’s spokesman Les Garcia says the horses were noticed Thursday morning by a motorist. Garcia says that the horses had food, but their water trough was empty. Two other dehydrated horses were found alive and taken to an animal hospital. A veterinarian says one horse is in good condition, but described the condition of the second horse as “touch and go.” Garcia says the horses’ owner showed up Thursday afternoon and was questioned by authorities.

The owner was “questioned?” I’d do far more than question him. But between dealing out my method of punishment, I guess I’d get around to asking a few questions. Here they are:

1. At what point were you going to get around to checking on your horses’ water?
2. How long have you gone without water?
3. Where, exactly, did your horses rank on your list of priorities?
4. What motivated you to ever acquire these horses in the first place?
5. If you could communicate with the dead horses (which you allowed to die a horrible death from dehydration), what would you say to them?

And if that horrible episode wasn’t enough, about a week later a cute miniature horse was stolen from a nearby high school’s agriculture department. The little gelding, named Gunner, resided in a posh, covered corral at Rubidoux High School, a dusty rural community over the hill from my town. The kids in the Ag Department cared for Gunner and in return he served as the school’s mascot. Known for his puppy dog disposition—one of the students said he’d follow anyone anywhere—sweet little Gunner had been stolen once before. That time, he’d been found unharmed in the possession of a teenaged thief who claimed he’d found Gunner loose alongside the road. Yeah, right.

This time, however, didn’t have a happy ending. Even though Gunner’s corral had been chained and padlocked, someone busted into the corral and stole Gunner again. He was missing for over a week as students and faculty placed fliers around town. Local newspaper articles included pleas to return the little pinto. Then, just a few days ago, it was reported that Gunner’s body had been found in a flood control channel on the outskirts of Rubidoux. Because the little equine body had already been disposed of, no one could tell what had caused Gunner’s death.

Had he been abused before he died? What was the purpose behind stealing a live animal, anyway? Surely Gunner hadn’t been seen as some sort of pawn in a high school prank. I mean, stealing a miniature horse is not quite the same as toilet papering a rival team’s football field before the homecoming game.

Quite often I wonder about what lurks in the hearts of some members of the human race. There’s got to be a special place for people who neglect and mistreat horses. And it sure isn’t Horse Heaven.

Back to Life with Horses

View Comments

  • I can't believe what some people are capable of. My parents taught us to love and care for any pet we had. I am teaching my kids the same. Some people are clueless that animals of any kind have feelings and needs to eat and drink like we do. It breaks my heart that they suffer on account of some stupid , ignorant and cruel " so called human beings".

  • The story about the missing miniature horse breaks my heart. I have two minis and can't imagine someone stealing them and later finding their bodies. I just can't understand why someone would do that. If you are going to steal them at least love them, don't hurt them....

  • OUR LOCAL NEWSPAPER JUST RAN AN INTERVIEW WITH THE WOMAN WHO FOALED AND RAISED "GUNNER," THE MINI THAT SHE DONATED TO THE HIGH SCHOOL. OF COURSE SHE IS JUST REALLY UPSET THAT THE LITTLE GUY MET SUCH A SAD END. THERE IS STILL AN ACTIVE INVESTIGATION INTO GUNNER'S THEFT AND ULTIMATE DEMISE. I CERTAINLY HOPE THAT THE SHERIFF IS GOING BACK TO THE KIDS WHO TOOK HIM LAST TIME. MY MIND CAN'T WRAP AROUND WHY SOMEONE WOULD BE MOTIVATED THROUGH JEALOUSY OR REVENGE TO HARM A MINIATURE HORSE. OR MAYBE THEY'RE JUST IDIOTS.
    AS FOR THE GUY WHO ALLOWED HIS HORSES TO DIE OF THIRST IN THE MIDST OF A CALIFORNIA SUMMER... I'M HOPING KARMA COMES TO PAY HIM A CALL.

  • That's awful. I just ask myself...why? Why would someone take the time to steal Gunner and possibly hurt him? If you don't like him fine, but why would someone hate him that much to do that? I just don't get it.

  • I don't understand how anyone can harm a horse. They need us to care for them. It's not like they can fend for themselves when they are fenced in. How the owner in CA could leave the herd without water is awful? He will get his due in the end

  • My little paint mare Shawnee was rescued because the previous owner couldn't afford the feed. At least she had enough sense to find a home for her horse before she starved to death. I'm a firm believer that one should not own an animal of any sort if he/she cannot take care of it.

  • Poor little sweet, innocent Gunnar. May he play with my Brew up in heaven. As for the folks who did this to him, there is a special place in hell for them. I'm sure of that.
    As for the people who left their horses with no water, I think they should be put in jail.

Recent Posts

AHP Equine Industry Survey Returns in 2025

Horse owners who live in the United States, are 18 years of age and older, and currently own or manage…

2 days ago

Is My Horse Cold? – An Excerpt from Keeping Horses Outdoors by Iveta Jebáčková-Lažanská

Is your horse cold in the winter? The following excerpt from Keeping Horses Outdoors by Iveta Jebáčková-Lažanská helps answer that question…

2 days ago

ASPCA Right Horse Adoptable Horse of the Week: Hali

Welcome to Horse Illustrated’s weekly installment of the Right Horse Adoptable Horse of the Week, offered in partnership with the…

3 days ago

Common Horse Training Mistakes

These four common horse training mistakes are easier to catch and correct when you’re aware of them. As a clinician,…

4 days ago

All About the American Warmblood

If you appreciate sport horses of many different breeding backgrounds, types and colors, the American Warmblood will unite you with…

6 days ago

Waste: ReImagined – ZahnTech Repurposes Waste for a Permanent Fencing Solution

LENNOX, S.D. — Every great innovation begins with a moment of clarity, and for ZahnTech's founder, Avery Zahn, it came…

1 week ago